Welcome to Bake Shop Bakes

Sorry Grandma, Ours are better

Whether you are looking for a Dine-In, home cooking expereince, or if you want to dig into our deliciously famous Apple Dumplings, Bake Shop Bakes has you covered!


Start a FundraiserCatering

Who We Are

We make all our bakery items with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients.

In 2012, Brittany and Andy Hoover took a chance that not too many people would have taken. With a family of six, Andy worked in construction and Brittany was a stay-at-home mom. One day Brittany went to the grocery store to purchase some apples to make apple pie. Brittany had previously attended culinary school. That evening she made the pie and after the first taste, Andy knew that everyone needed to try it. So they shared the pie with close family and friends. Everyone enjoyed the pie so much and encouraged them to start the business.

They started the business by selling various baked goods at a few local stores and doing small fundraisers. Since then, Bake Shop Bakes has grown into Central Pennsylvania’s premium bakery and community fundraiser!

Bakery Menu

All items are customizable

Homemade Cakes

  • $28.50 FOR 10″ ROUND
  • $29.75 FOR 1/4 SHEET
  • $41.99 FOR 1/2 SHEET
Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble cakes covered in our homemade icing, including Buttercream, Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Cream Cheese


  • $16.89 DOZEN
Fresh, homemade donuts filled with a wide variety of customizable homemade filling.

Fresh Baked Bread

  • $5.50 PER LOAF
Everything from white, wheat, rye, or Italian (and everything in between)

Cup Cakes

$15.00 Dozen
Same varieties as our Homemade Cakes


  • $1.99 EA
  • $8.99 A DOZEN
Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, Iced Sugar Cookie, Peanut Butter Blossom, and Chocolate Chocolate Chunk

Box of Brownies (9 Pieces)

Our delicious brownies come in plain, peanut butter, or walnut

Cinnamon Buns

  • $10.50 4 PACK
Our Cinnamon Buns come with or without icing

Apple Dumplings

Take a bite into our world famous Apple Dumplings


Bake Shop Bakes is expanding through Central Pennsylvania with each locations showcasing it’s own menu! Check back often and keep up to date!